#40 - What Happens Below the Fold

Ariel Ariel
5 minute read 12/21/21

Have you ever looked at search results in the App Store and wondered why they're ranked the way they are? In this series of Keyword Teardowns we analyze how the algorithm works and highlight tips and tricks to help you rank higher.

#40 - What Happens Below the Fold

If you look at enough search results, you'll inevitably come across a keyword (or 6) where the results make sense at the top, but as you start scrolling, they seem to become weirder and weirder. Once you analyze those, though, you'll see they follow the rules just as well.

Apple's and Google's search algorithms are black boxes and completely undocumented. But when you look at enough data, patterns start to emerge. I analyze thousands of search results to reverse engineer how the stores decide which apps to rank and how to rank them. I share what I learn for you to learn from and get more visibility.

Keyword: Podcast Player

49 moderate 97 very high 206 very low 1.6M very high

Podcasting has really taken off in 2021 thanks in part to Spotify and Joe Rogan, but also thanks to the endless amount of content that's available and doesn't require starting into a screen. Although Apple has an app that's built into the iPhone for listening to podcasts, it's not the only option. I analyzed one of those a few months ago, and in this teardown we're going to look at the keyword, but go a bit deeper.

Search results for "Podcast player" in the U.S App Store

The Podcast App is the top results, and it's there because it leads in terms of ratings even though it isn't using the full keyword in its visible metadata. But the ratings + having the second half in the invisible keyword list (and likely early on) give it the force it needs to rise to the top.

FYI - I've noticed a shift after iOS 15 where the keyword list is getting more love from the algorithm. I'm not sure how much more than before, but it feels like it's more important. So, make sure you're treating your keyword list well.

Monitor. Optimize. Grow

Get actionable insights in minutes!

Right behind it is Castbox, and Castbox is doing a great job because it puts the keyword right up front and managed to get to the top of these search results with fewer ratings than the top app. But it can do better. Can you spot the error here?

Yes, it's the duplication between the name and the subtitle. Without it, the results could be better. And there's not much better than #1.

Here's where things start to get weird.

At #3 we have Overcast, which manages to amplify its couple hundred ratings by having such few keywords in its name and subtitle that there's really nothing else for the algorithm to see. I have a feeling this isn't by design, but it's an interesting strategy to employ.

The thing is, it limits the reach this app can have. So if you want to try this, make sure you do your keyword research right and place as many relevant modifier keywords in your long description.

And in 4th we have Google, the app you'd expect would rank higher but doesn't have the word "player" in its visible metadata and also has much fewer ratings than what I expected. But then again, why would you download Google's podcast player on your iPhone? I have a feeling the name here isn't enough to battle Apple's built-in app or any of the more feature-rich 3rd party apps.

The Podcast Player, in #5, is a great example of almost doing things right. Look at that name, it's the keyword. And that's why it's even showing up in the top 5 with just a handful of ratings. But... it's also duplicating. So it can do better.

Below the Fold

Extended search results for "Podcast player" in the U.S App Store

FYI - I draw the fold line at 5, which is pretty arbitrary but is as much the target line as it is where I think attention drops off like a cliff.

Right below the fold we have Spotify. Yup, Spotify is also in this list and isn't at the top. That's because it doesn't have the word "player" anywhere in its visible metadata. But it's weird because it has so many ratings that this would only indicate it's not using the word "player" anywhere in its keyword list, and something about that feels wrong to me.

I don't know if that's the case or not, but I do know Apple and Spotify aren't the best of friends. I wouldn't be too surprised if that has anything to do with it.

Stitcher, in #7, is the first app that only leverages the subtitle to rank. That's exactly why it's below the fold. But wait, it's also got "podcasts" in its name! It does, but it's a duplicate. Those are no good...

In the 8th spot we have iHeart, which is running an error counter of two by duplicating and not including both parts of the keyword in its visible metadata. The first one is the bigger issue, so that's an easy fix. Including "player" in the name or subtitle is more of a brand choice, considering the type of app, which is a much more challenging one for any ASO (App Store Optimizer).

Branding and keywords don't always align, and that can create a dilemma. But, ultimately, it's all about visibility. Keep that in mind.

Podbean (which is what we use for our podcast) repeats too many things too many times, and in doing that, it isn't just devaluing it but also reversing the order of keywords, which we've seen isn't great. Both are easy fixes...

Last is Pocket Casts, which seems to be doing an alright job having a lot of focus but just doesn't have enough ratings to compete. Our estimates show quite a few downloads, which means it can get more ratings if it really tired.

It's worth a try!

What You Need to Know

Getting "above the fold" starts with proper keyword research and correct placement. One thing's clear: duplication isn't good for business. But, you should know this by now.

And that's all I have for you today. Subscribe to the newsletter for a new Keyword Teardown next week. If you have any questions or comments, you can find me on Twitter.

Are You Putting My Tips to Good Use?

App Store Optimization is part art and part science. I say it a lot, and I mean it. The art part is what I've been talking about in this Keyword Teardown and in my App Teardowns. The science part is where our simple and intuitive ASO tools come into play.

See where your apps are ranked, track trends, learn from competitors, get smart suggestions, and more, here.

Tagged: #aso

Related Resources

When Everyone's Making the Same Mistakes...
Keyword Teardowns
When Everyone's Making the Same Mistakes...

Want to find keyword opportunities? This is what you should be looking for.

The Answer to Competition is... Focus
Keyword Teardowns
The Answer to Competition is... Focus

This is how can new apps and games compete for better search results on the App Store.